Houses
Of The Holy Sessions
December 1971 - November 1972
DECEMBER
1971 - STARGROVES, NEWBURY, BERKSHIRE, UNITED KINGDOM
The date and location is still speculative, but since the band was
touring extensively during that time, it is possibly that this short
clip comes from one of the initial rehearsals they did for the forthcoming
album.
Recording
Includes:
Untitled Instrumental (take 1), Untitled Instrumental (take 2), Dancing
Days (take 1, instrumental), Dancing Days (take 2, instrumental), Dancing
Days (take 3, instrumental) [ cut throughout ].
Source: Incomplete very good to excellent
cassette demo recordings. Almost 5 minutes.
A
real mystery, this recording features some very obscure fragments. The
first instrumental take is a very nice acoustic melody, sounding much
different from anything we know. The second instrumental take is another
surprise. A fully electric rehearsal featuring the whole band jamming
on some unknown tune. However, the most interesting part of this short
tape are three takes of Dancing Days, during which we can follow Page
composing this classic song. The structure is not yet fully polished.
The first take is actually still highly improvised attempt, but in the
second and third ones you can already hear the well-known main guitar
riff.
DECEMBER 1971
- ISLAND STUDIOS, NOTTING HILL, LONDON, UNITED KINGDOM
Commonly attributed to one of the mixing sessions that took place
in Electric Lady Studios, New York City, New York on June 1972, these
takes are more likely comes from this period of time. They are also
sounding not as rehearsed than the rough mix originally recorded on
December 3, 1971 except for the final take, which sounds identical minus
vocals and middle guitar section.
Recording
Includes: No Quarter
(take 1, instrumental with count-in), [ cut ], No Quarter (take
2, instrumental with count-in), No Quarter (take 3, instrumental with
count-in), No Quarter (take 4, instrumental with count-in), [ cut
], No Quarter (take 5, with count-in), No Quarter (take 6, with count-in),
No Quarter (take 7, rough mix with count-in, vocals and overdubs).
Source: Almost complete excellent soundboard
recording. 25 minutes.
Bootleg
LP Reference(s): Studio Daze
(Scorpio)
Bootleg
CD Reference(s): Alternates
And Outtakes Led Zeppelin IV & Physical Graffiti Volume 3 (Boogie
Mama), Evolution Is Timing 2 (Empress Valley Supreme Disc box), The
Lost Sessions Volume 6 (Empress Valley Supreme Disc), Sessions (Antrabata
Reference Master box), Scorpio Rising (Akashic), Studio Magik - Sessions
1968-1980 (Godfatherecords box), & Studio Sessions Ultimate (Scorpio
box)
What
we have here is a fine example of the evolution of one of the most iconic
tunes the band ever made! The first take opens with Bonham banging the
sticks and singing The Who's Pictures Of Lily verse before Jones begins
the familiar cold organ intro. This is a complete seven minute run-through
without vocals or guitar solo, but with the same timbre of the official
version. Bonham starts his middle section a bit timidly and without
confidence compared to the next attempts. The second take is thirty
seconds and is aborted by Jones with a giggle. This is followed by another
attempt stopped after twenty seconds since Jones hits a bum note. After
that the second full run-through starts, lasting another seven minutes.
Again no vocals, guitar solo or grand piano is present, but Jones and
Bonham change the rhythm during the solo. After two more aborted takes,
with Jones hitting a really nasty note, we are rewarded with the final
take of the song. This one is complete with vocals, guitar solo, and
grand piano flourishes in the middle section. There are also additional
effects and more guitar tracks by Page. Some Plant moans were eventually
cut out of the final release. Finally, this is also the take that sounds
almost identical to the version released on companion disc.
DECEMBER 3,
1971 - ISLAND STUDIOS, NOTTING HILL, LONDON, UNITED KINGDOM
Recording
Includes: No Quarter
(rough mix with keyboard overdubs and without vocals).
Source: Complete superb soundboard recording.
7 minutes.
Official
LP Reference(s): Houses
Of The Holy "deluxe" and "super deluxe" editions
(Atlantic)
Official
CD Reference(s): Houses
Of The Holy "deluxe" and "super deluxe" editions
(Atlantic)
This is already well rehearsed and maturated mix with the excellent
piano overdubs, spacey Theremin section and the drums sounds so crystal
and clear in this version. Another well up tears moment is at the point
where the expected guitar solo has yet to be added and Jones extends
his keyboard input on grand piano that sounds just superb. His input
here has the feel of the live versions from the era. More keyboard overdubs
are presented as the song fades out. This is an enlightening rough attempt
that highlights John Paul Jones incredible contribution to this masterpiece.
This is also definitely a showcase of the rhythm section captured here
in one of their finest moments ever. The guitar is almost inaudible
throughout, allowing Bonham to really come through.
APRIL 30,
1972 - OLYMPIC SOUND STUDIOS, BARNES, LONDON, UNITED KINGDOM
Over The Hills And Far Away is yet still under its initial title,
Next One. Houses Of The Holy was originally recorded at Olympic Sound
Studios, Barnes, London, United Kingdom on April 12, 1972. Over The
Hills And Far Away was originally recorded at Olympic Sound Studios,
Barnes, London, United Kingdom on April 16, 1972.
Recording
Includes: Houses Of
The Holy (rough mix with overdubs), Over The Hills And Far Away (instrumental
guitar mix backing track).
Source: Complete superb soundboard recording.
8 minutes.
Official
LP Reference(s): Houses
Of The Holy "deluxe" and "super deluxe" editions
(Atlantic) & Physical Graffiti "deluxe" and "super
deluxe" editions (Atlantic)
Official
CD Reference(s): Houses
Of The Holy "deluxe" and "super deluxe" editions
(Atlantic) & Physical Graffiti "deluxe" and "super
deluxe" editions (Atlantic)
Houses
Of The Holy is an interesting rough take with overdubs, the guitar riff
is recorded with less compression, giving it a much chunkier if not
live sound. Robert's initial vocals have less echo and are pleasingly
upfront and clear. Bonzo's cowbell is much more pronounced, and the
backing vocal "oooh oooh" is also higher in the mix, and you
can clearly hear a tambourine as additional percussion towards the close.
Over The Hills And Far Away is a bit of disappointment in opposition.
It has no revelation anywhere, and it sounds already very close to the
finished album version except for some small details. The biggest difference
is when the acoustic guitar cuts back in after the middle solo, it sounds
like it has been pasted at the end rather erratically, making this section
a bit jarring. It could have been mixed more precisely, but we can guess
this is just one of a so-called reference takes.
APRIL/MAY
1972 - PUDDLETOWN, RIVER PIDDLE, DORSET, UNITED KINGDOM
Jimmy Page rehearsals extensively on various songs for the upcoming
album, on which there are documented evidences of working on The Song
Remains The Same (then known still as The Plumpton And Worcester Races)
and The Rain Song (then known still as The Seasons aka best One Yet).
MAY
1972 - OLYMPIC SOUND STUDIOS, BARNES, LONDON, UNITED KINGDOM
The Rain Song is still yet under its initial title, The Seasons
aka Best One Yet. The initial rehearsals were done at Puddletown, River
Piddle, Dorset, United Kingdom. Due to the information given on the
official Jimmy Page's YouTube channel, the first set of recordings were
done at Olympic Sound Studios, Barnes, London, England, and then were
moved to Stargroves, Newbury, Berkshire, United Kingdom with Rolling
Stones Mobile Studio. However, the date and location is speculative.
Recording
Includes:
The Rain Song (instrumental mix).
Source: Complete superb soundboard recording.
6 minutes.
The
newly surfaced instrumental mix that has been published on the official
Jimmy Page's YouTube channel. In his own words, the original idea for
the opening tracks for Houses of the Holy was that a short overture
would be a rousing instrumental introduction with layered electric guitars
that would segue in to The Seasons, later known as The Rain Song. Again,
there would be a contrasting acoustic guitar instrumental movement with
the Mellotron that could lead to the first vocal of the album and the
first verse of the song. This composition was a memo to Jimmy as a reminder
of the sequence of the song and various ideas he would have for it in
its embryonic stage. He worked on it over one evening at home. During
the routing of the overture then titled The Plumpton and Worcester Races,
the half-time section was born, and the overture shaped in to The Song
Remains The Same. The difference between this and later version used
on the companion disc is that it is played a bit faster, the heavy middle
segment as well as drums are completely absent, and the overdubs are
still not completed. A real treasure!
MAY 15, 1972
- ROLLING STONES MOBILE STUDIO, STARGROVES, NEWBURY, BERKSHIRE, UNITED
KINGDOM
One of vocal takes was later mixed at The Sol Studios, Cookham, Berkshire,
United Kingdom and released on Coda album in 1982. Black Country Woman
was also recorded during that time, yet still under its initial title,
What's The Matter Here.
Recording
Includes: Walter's Walk
(take 1, instrumental), Walter's Walk (take 2, rough mix with vocal
overdubs), Walter's Walk (take 3, rough mix with vocal overdubs).
Source: Complete very good to excellent
& superb soundboard recording. 13 minutes.
Official
LP Reference(s): Coda
(Swan Song)
Official
CD Reference(s): Coda
(Swan Song)
Bootleg
CD Reference(s): Coda
Advanced Tapes (Boogie Mama), Different Mixed Coda (POT), Evolution
Is Timing 2 (Empress Valley Supreme Disc box), The Lost Sessions Volume
8 (Empress Valley Supreme Disc), Sessions (Antrabata Reference Master
box), Studio Magik - Sessions 1968-1980 (Godfatherecords box), &
Studio Sessions Ultimate (Scorpio box)
Initially,
it was the instrumental track recorded during the rehearsals and recording
of Houses Of The Holy. This tune would find its way into Dazed And Confused
during their eighth North American tour in 1972, and it has been later
resurrected on the Coda album. This is primarily a rather simple
but monumental sounding, guitar dominated composition concentrated around
the heavy sounding rhythm section. Bonham plays one of his best drum
licks ever achieved on tape, he simply leads the band throughout. The
first take is instrumental and has much longer ending which end with
a final hit on the drums, while others two have vocal overdubs and the
ending fades out. Worth to note is that Plant recorded his parts at
that time for Coda sessions, and this represents his final known vocal
performance as a member of Led Zeppelin. It is also confirmed that while
producing the album, only the original guitar parts were a remainder
of this session.
MAY 16, 1972
- ROLLING STONES MOBILE STUDIO/STARGROVES, NEWBURY, BERKSHIRE, UNITED
KINGDOM
Mixed at The Sol Studio, Cookham, Berkshire, United Kingdom. While
producing the album, only the original guitar licks were a remainder
of this session. The rest of parts were recorded (minus the drum tracks)
and finished after 1980. Some reports says that Page also played the
bass track.
Recording
Includes: Walter's Walk
(jnstrumental rough mix).
Source: Complete superb soundboard tape.
3 minutes.
Official
LP Reference(s): Coda
"deluxe" and "super deluxe" editions (Swan Song)
Official
CD Reference(s): Coda
"deluxe" and "super deluxe" editions (Swan Song)
Brash
instrumental take, sourced probably from the session that took place
one day before, and smoothly edited in the studio. It sounds just about
the same as the instrumental take from the already mentioned recording
session listed above, but it is shortened for more than a minute. The
clarity and instruments separation are exceptional, though. It also
fades out at the end, just like the vocal version.
MAY 30, 1972
- OLYMPIC SOUND STUDIOS, BARNES, LONDON, UNITED KINGDOM
The Song Remains The Same is yet still under its initial title, The
Overture aka The Plumpton And Worcester Races. It was originally recorded
at Stargroves, Newbury, Berkshire, United Kingdom on Rolling Stones
Mobile Studio on May 18, 1972. The Crunge (originally recorded at Olympic
Sound Studios, Barnes, London, United Kingdom on April 16, 1972.
Recording
Includes: The Song Remains
The Same (guitar overdub reference mix), The Crunge (rough mix - keys
up).
Source: Complete superb soundboard recording.
Near 9 minutes.
Official
LP Reference(s): Houses
Of The Holy "deluxe" and "super deluxe" editions
(Atlantic)
Official
CD Reference(s): Houses
Of The Holy "deluxe" and "super deluxe" editions
(Atlantic)
The
wonderful The Song Remains The Same is a real gem. What we can examine
with this instrumental version are all these repetitive lead parts that
were significantly shortened, as they have way more impact on the album
version. Page plays very softly on the new lead parts, and the entire
composition has more breath. It's almost as though he went through the
song, removed all the air and had Plant add lyrics in those parts to
finish the tune. This alternate mix that stands not so far away from
the original release also shows Jimmy's guitar army at his best. The
Crunge is also very nice. The drums sound pretty punchy, almost like
live version. The bass is also much exposed here, with much more ambient
in the mix. A bit of difference in the keyboard towards the end is present.
AUGUST 4,
1972 - OLYMPIC SOUND STUDIOS, BARNES, LONDON, UNITED KINGDOM
Originally recorded at Olympic Sound Studios, Barnes, London, United
Kingdom on April 12, 1972.
Recording
Includes: Dancing Days
(rough mix with vocal).
Source: Complete superb soundboard recording.
Near 4 minutes.
Official
LP Reference(s): Houses
Of The Holy "deluxe" and "super deluxe" editions
(Atlantic)
Official
CD Reference(s): Houses
Of The Holy "deluxe" and "super deluxe" editions
(Atlantic)
This
alternate version is better than the official release because of one
thing and one thing only, John Bonham. With the guitar overdubbing stripped
down, the clarity of the drums and specifically the cymbals highlights
the memorizing drum playing by Bonzo. The added clarity of the cymbals'
breath new life into this song. Jones' bass is also much more clear
and also sounds incredible. However, another recently revealed alternative
mix posted on Jimmy Page's official YouTube channel, titled The Seasons,
completely beats this version.
AUGUST 9,
1972 - OLYMPIC SOUND STUDIOS, BARNES, LONDON, UNITED KINGDOM
The Rain Song is yet still under its initial title, The Seasons aka
Best One Yet. Originally recorded at Stargroves, Newbury, Berkshire,
United Kingdom on Rolling Stones Mobile Studio on May 18, 1972.
Recording
Includes: The Rain Song
(mix minus piano).
Source: Complete superb soundboard recording.
Near 8 minutes.
Official
LP Reference(s): Houses
Of The Holy "deluxe" and "super deluxe" editions
(Atlantic)
Official
CD Reference(s): Houses
Of The Holy "deluxe" and "super deluxe" editions
(Atlantic)
The
acoustic on the right channel sounds superb, as does the electric on
the left. Kind of reminds us of the Unledded version. The strings sound
superb. The drums are a perfect balance. This should have gone on the
album in the first place, just like Dancing Days from the above session.
Furthermore, if we focus on the acoustic channel hard enough, then we
find piano. Why it has been removed really is a mystery and a sort of
disappointment. Anyway, this take sounds much more reacher in some arrangements
and instruments separation is definitely better. A great discovery,
but they should choose the instrumental alternate mix released on the
official Jimmy Page's YouTube channel on the companion disc instead.
OCTOBER 19,
1972 - EMI STUDIOS, BOMBAY, INDIA
Robert Plant and Jimmy Page rehearsals with Bombay Symphony Orchestra
conducted by Vijay Ragav Rao. Four Sticks is re-named as Four Hands
on the companion disc for Coda album.
Recording
Includes: Friends (rehearsing
the tune) [ cut ], [ cut ], Four Sticks (take 1, orchestra
only), [ cut ], Friends (take 1, orchestra only), Friends (take
2, with guitar, vocals and orchestra), Friends (take 3, with guitar,
vocals and orchestra), [ cut ], Four Sticks (take 2, orchestra
only), Four Sticks (take 3, orchestra only), [ cut ], Four Sticks
(take 4, orchestra only) [ cut ].
Source: Incomplete excellent soundboard
recording. 52 minutes.
Recording
Includes: Four Sticks
(orchestra only), Friends (with guitar and vocal).
Source: Complete superb soundboard recording.
9 minutes.
Official
LP Reference(s): Coda
"deluxe" and "super deluxe" editions (Swan Song)
Official
CD Reference(s): Coda
"deluxe" and "super deluxe" editions (Swan Song)
Bootleg
LP Reference(s): The
Making Of Friends (III)
Bootleg
CD Reference(s): All
That Glitters Is Gold (Celebration Definitive Masters), Alternates And
Outtakes III Volume 2 (Boogie Mama), Complete 1972 Bombay Sessions (Tecumseh
Recording Co.), Evolution Is Timing 2 (Empress Valley Supreme Disc box),
The Lost Sessions Volume 2 (Empress Valley Supreme Disc), Sessions (Antrabata
Reference Master box & The Diagrams Of Led Zeppelin), The Smithereens
(Akashic, 1CD & 3CD box), Studio Magik - Sessions 1968-1980 (Godfatherecords
box), & Studio Sessions Ultimate (Scorpio box)
Page
and Plant recruited famous Indian musician Vijay Ragav Rao to assemble
an ad hoc orchestra comprised of both Western and Indian instruments.
What can be clearly heard are both Jimmy Page and Robert Plant speaking
to Rao, and Rao translating their instructions to the musicians. The
orchestra tries their best, but the different takes reveal missed cues
and misunderstandings. This is the first time they tried to interpret
their musical ideas to anyone other than members of the band, and they
have difficulty in explaining what they want. Rehearsals exist only
for Friends, as well as a very good final take with vocals. For the
Four Sticks, the other eastern inspired tune they practice, only more
polished takes without vocals exist. The official tracks have better
stereo separation and precise quality is also much improved over bootlegs.
Still a gem and something worth of attention.
NOVEMBER 16,
1972 - OLYMPIC SOUND STUDIOS, BARNES, LONDON, UNITED KINGDOM
Originally recorded at Olympic Sound Studios, Barnes, London, United
Kingdom on April 15, 1972.
Recording
Includes: The Ocean
(working mix).
Source: Complete superb soundboard recording.
4 minutes.
Official
LP Reference(s): Houses
Of The Holy "deluxe" and "super deluxe" editions
(Atlantic)
Official
CD Reference(s): Houses
Of The Holy "deluxe" and "super deluxe" editions
(Atlantic)
This
is the last song on the album and also the last one on the companion
disc. There is no famous introduction and count-in at the start. The
guitar is favoured over the bass throughout a bit. The solo is mixed
in, but we can dig the live feel to it. The drums coming through crystal
clear and the bass is well exposed finally, but between this and album
version no big difference is detected.
|